Belfast · Glengormley · Carrickfergus · Serving All of Northern Ireland

Erb's Palsy Claims & Compensation in Northern Ireland

Contact us for a free consultation with a qualified solicitor on claiming for compensation following birth complications that led to a child's diagnosis of Erb's palsy.

Erb's palsy Nerve damage to a baby's shoulder and arm during birth, often following shoulder dystocia that was poorly managed.
55+ years of firm experience acting for injured people in Northern Ireland
Claims involving the health & social care trusts, private healthcare professionals, GPs and dentists
Free initial consultation, no obligation to proceed
Caitriona Forde, Solicitor
Caitriona Forde, Solicitor Leading our medical negligence claims, and known for the empathetic and thorough way she manages cases. Speak to Caitriona's team for free, confidential advice.

Erb's Palsy

Erb's palsy is a nerve injury that results in partial or complete loss of muscle function, weakness or paralysis of a new-born's upper limb. It is often caused by excessive force being applied, or procedures not being followed appropriately by medical professionals, when trying to free a baby's shoulder that has become stuck behind the mother's pelvis, a scenario known as shoulder dystocia. If the medical professionals involved with the birth were negligent and their negligence resulted in the child developing Erb's palsy, the child is entitled to compensation to ensure a life that is as comfortable and independent as possible.

Paschal O'Hare Solicitors have a dedicated medical negligence team with experience in working through the complexities of an Erb's palsy claim and supporting the client through to the claim's conclusion.

Your first step is to get in touch with Paschal O'Hare Solicitors.

What a claim has to establish

A duty of care was owed to you. Between a healthcare professional and his or her patient, this is rarely in dispute.
The care fell below the standard expected of a reasonably competent professional in that field.
That failure caused your injury or made an existing condition materially worse.
You suffered loss as a result: physical, psychological, or financial.
Two tests

A bad outcome is not the same as negligence

You must prove both breach of duty and that the breach caused your injury.

Medicine carries risk. A treatment can go wrong, a condition can worsen, and an operation can leave you worse than before, all without anyone having done anything wrong. That is a hard thing to hear when you have been harmed, but this must be considered before any medical negligence claim can begin.

To succeed, a claim has to clear two separate hurdles. The first is breach of duty: proving that the care you received fell below the standard of a responsible body of medical opinion, and that the opinion defending it does not stand up to logical scrutiny. The second is causation: proving that the failure in care is what caused your injury, rather than your underlying illness or a recognised complication.

Causation is where most claims succeed or fail. For example, a doctor may accept that a diagnosis was missed and still argue that earlier diagnosis would have made no difference to the outcome. Input from independent medical experts is required to investigate and answer these often complex questions.

Who the claim is against

In most cases, you do not sue the doctor personally

Who you claim against depends on where you were treated.

Hospital treatment

Claims arising from treatment at a hospital run by one of Northern Ireland's health and social care trusts, and claims involving the Ambulance Service, are brought against the relevant trust and the NI Ambulance Service respectively. The treating clinician is not personally sued.

Private clinics and hospitals

A claim arising from private treatment is brought against the treating clinician.

GPs, dentists and others

A claim arising from treatment provided by GPs, dentists and other independent practitioners, such as pharmacists and opticians, is brought against the treating practitioner.

Time limits

How long do you have to bring a claim?

The time you have to bring a claim is known as the limitation period. Medical negligence claims differ from most accident claims because the negligence, or the harm caused by the negligence, may not be obvious at the time, and so the starting date of the limitation period in each medical negligence case requires careful consideration.

Standard rule

Three years, but from when?

Three years from the treatment in question, or from when you first reasonably became aware that you had a significant injury attributable to the care you received. Court proceedings must be started within the three year period, so it is important to make enquiries with a solicitor before it expires.

Injured children

Three years from their 18th birthday

When the treatment in question occurred when the patient was under 18, the limitation period does not begin until he or she turns 18. A claim can still be brought on a child's behalf before then by a parent or guardian acting as next friend.

Legal disability

Time limits may differ

Different rules may apply where the injured person is under a legal disability because of a qualifying mental disorder. This is a narrow legal test, not the same as lacking capacity for a single decision, and it applies only in limited circumstances. Do not assume it applies to your case. These situations need individual advice.

Courts have a limited discretion to allow a claim outside the three years where it is fair to do so, but it is granted only in restricted circumstances and should never be relied on as a reason to delay. Medical negligence claims also take time to investigate before proceedings can be issued, so early advice matters.

Speak to our medical negligence team

We offer you our preliminary opinion on the prospects of success and what you can expect from the process, to help you decide whether you would like to pursue a claim. Free initial consultation, no obligation to proceed.

Belfast: 1 Lanyon Quay, Oxford Street, BT1 3LG· Glengormley: 321 Antrim Road, BT36 5DY· Carrickfergus: 31 High Street, BT38 7AN