Unsafe Systems & Colleague Negligence Claims
Employers who put unsafe procedures in place, or who ignore the policies they are supposed to follow, put their employees at risk. The same is true where sound procedures exist on paper but are not followed by other members of staff. Contact us for a free consultation with a qualified solicitor about what happened to you.
Injured because of dangerous policies at work?
Employers who fail to provide safe systems of work, adequate training, supervision or appropriate risk controls can put employees at risk. Specific health and safety regulations may also apply, depending on the work being carried out. Employees can also be exposed to risk where safe procedures are in place but are not followed by other work colleagues.
We have a track record of identifying the cause of an injury and pursuing a claim on that basis. Alongside compensation for the injury itself, we can also help secure loss of earnings and other forms of special damages. Your first step is to get in touch.
Situations we deal with
"It was a colleague's mistake, not the company's"
An employer can still be responsible for what their staff do at work
This is one of the most common reasons people decide not to take advice. They assume that because a workmate caused it, there is nobody to claim against except that individual, and understandably nobody wants to pursue a colleague personally.
In practice that is not usually how it works. An employer can be held responsible for the negligence of an employee acting in the course of their work, so a claim of this kind is normally brought against the employer rather than the individual colleague. The employer's liability insurer will usually deal with the claim on the employer's behalf. This can apply even where the employee was carrying out their work in an unauthorised way, depending on the circumstances.
There is also a second route worth considering. Where a colleague's error was made possible by inadequate training, poor supervision, understaffing or unrealistic pressure, the employer's own failings may be part of the picture as well. Which of these applies will depend on the facts, and it is what we would look at with you.
How a safe system of work can break down
Claims of this kind tend to come from one of a small number of situations. Establishing which applies is the first thing we do.
The system itself was unsafe
The way the work was organised created the risk: no safe procedure at all, a procedure that never accounted for an obvious hazard, or one written for different conditions from the ones you were actually working in.
The system was not followed
A sound procedure existed but was not applied on the day, whether by you, a colleague or a supervisor. Where an employer knew that an unsafe shortcut had become routine and failed to address it, that may support a finding that the employer was at fault. The actions of the injured employee may also be considered when liability is assessed.
Nobody was checking
A written procedure that is never monitored does not keep anyone safe. Supervision is part of an employer's duty, and its absence is often what allows an unsafe practice to become normal.
If you raised a concern before the accident and nothing changed, tell us. A complaint made in advance can be significant, because it suggests the risk was known about.
What a claim may cover
General damages for the injury are assessed against the Green Book, the guidance Northern Ireland courts use, based on the injury and its effects.
The injury
Compensation for the injury itself and the effect it has had on your life, including any lasting consequences such as ongoing pain, restricted movement, scarring or psychological effects. These are assessed on the medical evidence.
Your financial losses
Loss of earnings, the cost of treatment, travel to appointments and help you have needed at home. Where the injury has affected what you can do at work in the longer term, that is assessed as well.
How long you have to bring a claim
Under Article 7 of the Limitation (Northern Ireland) Order 1989, the general limitation period for a personal injury action is three years, although the date from which that period runs can depend on the circumstances.
Generally three years
Court proceedings must generally be started within three years of the accident, or from the injured person's date of knowledge if that is later. Different rules and exceptions can apply, so it is sensible to seek advice as soon as possible. Witnesses move on and CCTV is often overwritten much sooner, so the practical window for gathering evidence can be considerably shorter.
Make sure it is formally recorded
A record made at the time can be valuable, particularly where a colleague was involved and accounts may differ later. This may be in the workplace accident book or another accident record. Ask for a copy of what was recorded where possible.
You can claim while working there
You do not have to leave your job before bringing a workplace injury claim. A claim is normally brought against the employer, with the employer's liability insurer usually dealing with it on the employer's behalf. If you are worried about how making a claim could affect your employment, speak to us about your concerns.
Workplace claims we have settled
Arthur's Serious Work Accident Claim
Arthur was standing beside a lorry during a loading operation when a heavy item was nudged and fell, trapping him from the ribs down. The way the operation was organised had failed to keep him clear of the load.
Read Arthur's story Belfast · Unexpected machine movementAllen's Serious Work Injury Claim
Allen was supervising in a Belfast factory when a forklift's forks closed unexpectedly on his head, fracturing his skull. He required ear reconstruction, plates in his jaw and psychiatric treatment. His employer disputed the extent of his injuries.
Read Allen's story Belfast · Colleague's errorGareth's Accident at Work Claim
A colleague working above Gareth lost his grip on a power tool, which fell and struck his foot. He went on to develop complex regional pain syndrome and two of his toes were amputated. His employer accepted liability.
Read Gareth's storyEvery claim is different and past settlements are not a guide to the value of any future claim. These are individual outcomes based on their own facts and evidence.
What to expect when you make a claim
Free initial consultation
We talk through what happened, how the work was supposed to be done and how it was actually being done. We will tell you honestly whether we think there is a claim worth pursuing.
Identifying the cause
We request the risk assessment and written procedure for the task, training and supervision records, the accident book entry and any CCTV, to establish whether the system or the way it was carried out was at fault.
Medical evidence
We arrange for you to be seen by an appropriate specialist so that the extent of the injury and its likely duration are properly established.
Negotiation and settlement
We negotiate with the employer's insurer and keep you updated. Where a fair figure cannot be agreed, we can issue proceedings rather than settle for less than we believe the claim is worth.
Unsafe systems and colleague negligence: common questions
A colleague caused my injury. Am I suing them personally?
Not usually. An employer can be held responsible for the negligence of an employee acting in the course of their work, so a claim of this kind is normally brought against the employer rather than the individual colleague. The employer's liability insurer will usually deal with the claim on the employer's behalf. We understand nobody wants to pursue a workmate, and that is worth raising with us at the outset.
My colleague was doing something they'd been told not to do. Does that matter?
It may not prevent a claim. An employer can still be responsible where an employee was acting in connection with their work, even if they were going about it the wrong way. It can also raise a separate question about supervision, and whether the employer knew the practice was going on.
There was a proper procedure. Nobody followed it. Can I still claim?
Possibly. Having a written procedure is not the same as making sure it is applied. Where an employer knew, or ought to have known, that a shortcut had become routine and did nothing about it, that failure to enforce may itself form the basis of a claim.
I raised a concern beforehand and nothing changed. Does that help?
It can matter a great deal, because it suggests the risk was already known about. An email, a message, an entry in a defect book or a complaint witnessed by a colleague are all useful. Tell us about it even if it was only raised verbally.
I was partly at fault myself. Is that the end of it?
Not necessarily. Where you share some responsibility, an award may be reduced to reflect your share of responsibility, which is known as contributory negligence. It does not by itself defeat a claim. Any reduction will depend on the particular facts and evidence.
Will my colleague get into trouble?
A civil claim for compensation is about establishing who was legally responsible, and it is handled between solicitors and insurers. What an employer does internally is a separate matter over which we have no control. It is a fair concern and we will talk through how the process is likely to run before anything is started.
Will a claim cost me anything?
In Northern Ireland, solicitors cannot enter into contingency fee arrangements or agreements under which their payment depends solely on the case succeeding. If your claim succeeds, we will usually seek recovery of your reasonable legal costs from the defendant. What can be recovered depends on the outcome, any settlement and the applicable costs rules. We explain the potential costs and financial risks before your claim proceeds, and your first consultation is free.
Speak to our work accident solicitors
Initial consultations are free, confidential, and carry no obligation. Tell us what happened and we will advise you honestly on where you stand.
Belfast: 1 Lanyon Quay, Oxford Street, BT1 3LG· Glengormley: 321 Antrim Road, BT36 5DY· Carrickfergus: 31 High Street, BT38 7AN