You're waiting at a junction when another car runs into the back of you. You both get out. You know what happened, but the other driver tells a completely different story. Now it's your word against theirs.
That's where an eyewitness can make all the difference. Someone with no stake in the outcome can say what they saw, and that can carry real weight in a claim.
Why independent witnesses matter
Everyone involved in an accident has a reason to see it their way. That doesn't mean your account isn't important. It is. But when two drivers disagree, an independent witness can settle the question of who was at fault.
A good witness can also protect you if the other side tries to blame you, and their account often helps a claim settle without the need for court.
Who can be a witness?
Anyone who saw or heard the accident happen, including:
- People walking past or waiting at a bus stop.
- Other drivers who weren't involved.
- Anyone who stopped to help.
- Staff or customers in nearby shops.
- People in nearby houses who saw it from a window.
How to get a witness's details
Your safety comes first. Only speak to witnesses once you're out of danger and have had any urgent medical help you need.
Then introduce yourself and politely ask what they saw. Take their name, phone number and email address, and write down what they tell you as soon as you can. They don't have to talk to you, so never push.
Let them tell it their way
Don't suggest what happened or ask leading questions like "You saw them run the red light, didn't you?" A witness's account carries more weight when it's clearly their own. Your solicitor can take a full statement from them later.
Act quickly
People's memories fade, and witnesses can be hard to track down weeks later. The sooner their details are taken and their account is recorded, the more useful it's likely to be.
Witnesses are one piece of the evidence. Dashcam footage, CCTV from nearby businesses, photos of the scene and the police report can all back up what they say, and fill gaps if they missed something.
What if there were no witnesses?
You may still be able to claim. Many accidents happen with nobody else around, and claims are often supported by other evidence, such as the damage to the vehicles, photos, footage and medical records. Whether you can claim depends on what happened and the evidence available.
Been in an accident that wasn't your fault?
Paschal O'Hare Solicitors has helped people across Northern Ireland since 1969. Talk to our team about what happened and whether you may have a claim.