What If the Other Driver Says the Accident Was Your Fault in Northern Ireland?

8 min read
What If the Other Driver Says the Accident Was Your Fault in Northern Ireland

Updated 14 November 2026

Being blamed for a car accident can leave you wondering whether there is any point in making a claim. That is particularly worrying when the other driver sounds certain and you have no dashcam recording to show what happened.

The other driver’s account does not decide the outcome. A claim can still be investigated when responsibility is disputed. What matters is whether the available evidence supports your case, including evidence that may be less obvious at first.

No dashcam?

A claim can still be investigated using other available evidence.

Evidence together

Photos, accounts and technical evidence each have different strengths and limits.

Act promptly

Prioritise safety and preserve information while it is still available.

What should you do after the collision?

Put safety and medical care first. Do not stand in traffic or delay treatment to take photographs. Call the emergency services where needed, exchange the required details and tell your own insurer about the collision.

The Northern Ireland Highway Code explains the duties to stop, exchange details and report to police in the circumstances covered by its rules. If details were not exchanged or you are unsure what is required, contact the police promptly.

Give an accurate account of what you remember. If you did not see something, or are uncertain about a distance or speed, say so. Keep any messages from the other driver and avoid getting drawn into an argument about blame.

How is fault decided in Northern Ireland?

In a civil claim, the person bringing the case must establish it on the balance of probabilities: in practical terms, that their case is more likely than not. The court considers the evidence as a whole, rather than simply accepting the more confident driver’s account. This standard is applied in Northern Ireland road accident judgments.

An insurer may reach its own assessment during negotiations. If responsibility remains contested and the case proceeds to a hearing, the court decides the disputed issues.

Can I still claim without witnesses or dashcam footage?

Yes, potentially. Neither an independent witness nor a dashcam recording is a requirement in every claim. Your own evidence and other material may help establish what happened. However, a lack of supporting evidence can make a disputed case harder to prove.

The useful question is what evidence still exists and what each item can reliably show.

Photographs of the vehicles and road layout

Photographs can record vehicle positions, junction markings, signs, visibility and nearby obstructions. Where safe, take wider views as well as close-ups. Keep the original files and note if vehicles had already been moved. A photograph taken afterwards may show the layout clearly without proving where each vehicle was at the moment of impact.

Damage to each vehicle

The location and pattern of damage can help test whether an account is consistent with the impact. Keep photographs, repair estimates and any engineer’s report. Damage alone does not necessarily establish speed, right of way or which driver changed lanes. Its significance depends on the circumstances and, where appropriate, expert interpretation.

Accounts recorded shortly after the accident

Write down the sequence of events while it is fresh, including your route, lane and the point at which you first saw the other vehicle. Separate what you observed from what you later assumed. Date any sketch and label it as an illustration. Preserve your original notes, even if you later need to add a correction or clarification.

CCTV or footage from another vehicle

You may not have a dashcam, but another vehicle, business or property may have recorded something relevant. Note possible cameras and the time and location of the collision. Tell your solicitor promptly so preservation and access can be explored. Recordings may be overwritten, and there is no single retention period that applies to every system. Access may also be restricted for privacy reasons.

Police information and relevant expert evidence

Police records may contain useful details, accounts or observations. A vehicle engineer or collision specialist may assist where a technical issue justifies their involvement. Expert evidence should address a specific question; it is not needed in every case.

Medical evidence serves a different purpose. It can help establish your injuries, their likely cause and recovery, but a medical report does not automatically prove which driver caused the collision.

An example of how evidence can fit together

Illustrative example, not a client case: two drivers disagree about a collision beside a junction. Neither has dashcam footage. One took photographs showing damage and road markings; the other says the vehicles had already moved. An engineer may help assess whether the damage fits the competing accounts, while nearby CCTV may show their approach. No single item necessarily resolves the dispute. Comparing them can identify what is supported, what remains uncertain and what further information would be useful.

What if both drivers were partly responsible?

Being partly responsible does not necessarily prevent a claim. Compensation may be reduced to reflect your share of responsibility for the damage. Northern Ireland’s rules on contributory negligence require that assessment to be fair in the circumstances; a disagreement between drivers does not automatically mean a 50/50 split. The approach is explained in this Northern Ireland judgment.

Does a lack of police prosecution end my claim?

No. The PSNI’s collision advice explains that a decision not to prosecute does not prejudice a civil action. A police investigation and a compensation claim have different purposes. You still need evidence supporting your civil claim.

Getting advice when responsibility is disputed

Bring the insurer’s explanation, your account, photographs and any reference numbers or witness details you have. You do not need a complete file before asking for advice.

Paschal O’Hare Solicitors handles road traffic accident claims across Northern Ireland. We can consider the disputed issues, the available evidence and what further enquiries may be appropriate. Contact us for a free initial consultation to discuss your circumstances.