What happened to Laura
Laura was travelling to Blackpool and the first leg of her journey involved taking the Stena Line ferry from Belfast to Cairnryan, Scotland. On arrival at the Scottish harbour, passengers were directed to the car deck to disembark. The only way to reach the appropriate deck was to walk down a six-foot ramp with no handrails on either side.
As she walked down the ramp, Laura tripped over metal trimming attached to each end of it. She fell and suffered a shoulder injury. She was taken to Stranraer Community Hospital, where an x-ray confirmed a dislocated shoulder.
As a result of the accident, Laura's trip was cancelled. She was required to wear a sling for three months and experienced severe, ongoing pain that affected every aspect of her daily life. Having previously used Paschal O'Hare Solicitors, she contacted us again without hesitation.
How we handled her claim
- On investigation, we established that the ramp was unsuitable for pedestrians and had been designed for wheelchair users. Stena Line investigated the matter but did not accept liability. They invited settlement negotiations on economic grounds.
- We arranged for Laura to be examined by a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon, who provided a medical report. The x-rays were reviewed and Laura also underwent an MRI scan carried out by a Consultant Radiologist. This established that she had suffered a rotator cuff tear in addition to the dislocation.
- The surgeon's opinion was that pain would persist without surgery and that a rotator cuff repair would give a 90% chance of alleviating symptoms. The estimated cost of surgery was £5,700. We presented this to Stena Line, but they refused to make any offer until the surgery had been performed. We considered this unacceptable and issued High Court proceedings.
- Proceedings were issued in Belfast despite the accident occurring in Scotland. Under the Athens Convention on sea travel, it is permissible to sue in the jurisdiction where the passenger embarked or disembarked. Stena Line also carries out business in Belfast and has a registered office in Northern Ireland.
- Once proceedings were issued, Stena Line appointed a defendant solicitor. Negotiations were entered prior to a court date.
The outcome
The case settled following negotiations with the defendant solicitor appointed by Stena Line, with proceedings already issued in Belfast's High Court.
What the NHS says about Laura's injury
A dislocated shoulder occurs when the upper arm bone is forced out of the shoulder socket, typically as the result of a fall or impact. Recovery can take several weeks and more serious associated injuries, such as a rotator cuff tear, may require surgery.
NHS Dislocated Shoulder — NHS informationHad an accident on a ferry or during travel?
If you've been injured during a trip, you may be entitled to compensation even if the accident happened outside Northern Ireland.