Thomas’s Workplace Accident Claim Settles for £22,500 (Portstewart)

5 min read
Workplace Accident Claim Portstewart

What happened to Thomas

Thomas was working as a café assistant at a busy coffee shop in Portstewart. During a shift, one of his colleagues mentioned that the bins were becoming full and that more room was needed. Thomas volunteered to compact the rubbish inside one of the bins.

While doing so, one of the bin's wheels moved into a drainage grate, causing Thomas to fall forward and land heavily on his elbow. He was taken to Causeway Hospital and later received further treatment at Altnagelvin Hospital, where he was diagnosed with a fracture dislocation of his elbow and required a cast and brace.


How we handled his claim

Thomas contacted Paschal O'Hare Personal Injury Solicitors, and his claim was handled by Partner Seymour Major.

Thomas's injuries included:

  • Fracture dislocation of elbow (cast and brace)
  • Potential for permanent pain and stiffness
  1. Medical evidence was obtained from an Orthopaedic Consultant, who confirmed that Thomas could experience some permanent pain and stiffness in his elbow.
  2. Liability was disputed by the defendant. It was alleged that Thomas had not been instructed to climb onto the bin and had chosen to do so himself.
  3. Court proceedings were issued on Thomas's behalf, and engineering evidence was obtained to further investigate the circumstances surrounding the accident.
  4. The case was listed for hearing, but an agreement was reached before the hearing took place. Thomas received £22,500 in compensation on a compromise basis.

Disputed liability doesn't mean no claim

Where a defendant contests responsibility, the case doesn't end. It moves forward on the evidence. We've covered this in more detail in our post on what happens when the other side denies liability.


The outcome

£22,500 + legal costs · Compromise settlement agreed before hearing

Thomas received £22,500 in compensation for his elbow injury and its likely long-term effects, agreed on a compromise basis once the case had been prepared for hearing.

"Workplace accident claims can become particularly challenging when there is a dispute over how an accident happened or what an employee was expected to do. In cases like Thomas's, it is important to look carefully at the working environment and all of the available evidence. Despite liability being strongly contested, we were able to progress the case to the point of hearing and secure a £22,500 settlement for Thomas."

Seymour Major, Partner, Paschal O'Hare Solicitors

Injured in an accident at work?

If you have been injured in a workplace accident in Northern Ireland, we can advise you on your options in a free initial consultation, including where liability is disputed.