What happened to Jack
Jack was riding his motorcycle when a car coming the opposite way cut across his path. He was knocked off his bike and thrown a significant distance across the road. Instinctively, Jack got up and then collapsed into a ditch. The police happened to be on the scene by chance.
Jack was taken by ambulance to the Royal Victoria Hospital, where he was detained for one week before being transferred to the Ulster Hospital, Dundonald. In total, he remained in hospital for eight weeks. As a result of the accident, Jack sustained multiple injuries across his body and underwent numerous surgeries.
How we handled his claim
On the recommendation of a family member, Jack instructed Patrick O'Hare of Paschal O'Hare Personal Injury Solicitors to pursue a personal injury claim on his behalf. From the outset, it was clear that Jack would be left with lifelong issues affecting his lower limbs.
Jack's injuries included:
- Multiple orthopaedic injuries
- Lifelong lower limb complications
- Chest injuries
- Scarring and soft tissue injuries
- Psychiatric injury
- Loss of chosen career
- Medical reports were obtained from a range of specialists to establish the full extent of Jack's injuries and their long-term consequences.
- Because Jack had been training to be a chef and could no longer pursue a career involving prolonged standing, an Occupational Psychologist was instructed to assess his employment prospects. An Occupational Therapy Consultant was also instructed to cost out Jack's care needs, both past and future, and a Forensic Accountant to calculate his financial loss over the same period.
- High Court proceedings were issued. Despite the driver having been convicted of causing grievous bodily harm by careless driving, the defence solicitors declined to accept civil liability. A Consulting Engineer's report was obtained, which established that the Defendant was at fault and that no blame attached to Jack.
- The matter was listed for trial. Negotiations took place both before and on the morning of the hearing, with successive offers made and rejected until an acceptable settlement was reached at £900,000 plus CRU.
- Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
- Psychiatrist
- Plastic Surgeon
- Thoracic Surgeon
- Occupational Psychologist
- Occupational Therapy Consultant
- Forensic Accountant
- Consulting Engineer
Conviction in the criminal court, denial in the civil court
Even where a driver has been convicted of a serious criminal offence arising out of a collision, it does not necessarily follow that their insurers will admit civil liability. In Jack's case, an engineering report was needed to establish the mechanics of the collision and dismantle the liability argument. Read more in our blog on what happens when the other side denies liability.
The negotiation journey
The final settlement figure wasn't reached in one step. It came out of three successive offers, each pushed back on the basis of the medical, care and financial evidence:
The outcome
The final settlement reflected the seriousness of Jack's orthopaedic injuries, the lifelong lower limb complications and the loss of his chosen career. It was reached after two earlier offers, £500,000 and £750,000, were both rejected on the basis of the evidence.
"I would just like to thank Patrick O'Hare of Paschal O'Hare Solicitors for the way he has handled this case. I am absolutely delighted with the outcome. I would have no hesitation recommending Paschal O'Hare Solicitors to anyone involved in a serious, life-changing accident."
Jack · ClientInjured in a motorcycle accident?
Our team acts for motorcyclists across Northern Ireland who have suffered serious injuries. Initial consultations are free and carry no obligation.